The following is an email exchange with an existing client:
Hi John,
I have read the Power of Zero book by Dave McKnight, along with listening to many of his podcasts. I seem to resonate with his approach to matters. Have you read, and are you a fan of his approach to things also?
Thanks.
My reply:
I am familiar the book and movie. The director, Doug
Orchard, actually produced and directed two of the videos on my website.
(The 2 videos are at top of the page here: https://jlmwealthstrategies.com/videos/)
I like the Power of Zero strategy with regards to how it
applies to indexed annuities. I do have a difference of opinion as it
applies to IUL’s because of the increasing cost of insurance within
those policies. I don’t believe the industry does a very good job of
disclosing the risks with IUL’s. The only mention of risk to a prospective buyer seems to be
that money can’t be lost if the market goes down. This is a half-truth at best.
There are actual risk esposures IUL's have but they are usually never mentioned. The cost of insurance in an IUL increases every year by a larger amount which poses a major problem
during retirement years. IUL are sold on the idea that the returns will be there, and while it is
possible they could be, but it’s also possible they won’t. Then what?
For this reason, I would only recommend an IUL for two sets of people:
1) High net
worth clients who can commit a minimum $20k a year while still maintaining
diversified portfolio of other assets AND life insurance policies.
2) Parents living with diabetes who cannot otherwise qualify for a permanent cash value policy. There is an IUL only program specifically designed for those with diabetes, currently unavailable with Whole Life.
Outside of these two demographics of people, I wouldn't recommend an IUL because I see too many
buyers of IUL putting the majority of resources into one IUL plan and
little elsewhere. It’s a recipe for disaster because here's what I know as an experienced advisor what go wrong with an IUL:
Here are 5 Perils of an IUL
1. The IUL cost of insurance is based on annual increasing one
year renewable term. Cheap when young, cost prohibitive once a person
hits retirement.
2. Returns could be below illustrated. The increasing cost of
insurance will only erode returns further.
3. Planned premium funding falls off because life happens. Examples include layoffs, an extra kid (or two!), unplanned college expenses, failing health, divorce, lack of financial discipline... even pandemics! Life does happen and failing to maximize the policy contributions of an IUL has an adverse effect
on the returns of the policy because less premium means less cash value potentially earning interest to offset internal increasing costs of the life insurance.
4. IUL’s never endow.
Only Whole Life policies can endow----
this means the cash value is guaranteed to equal the death benefit by age
121. The current cash value in a Whole Life policy is actually the present value of the future
death benefit. This is hard to grasp at first but it’s very
powerful.
Essentially, a Whole Life policy is reverse-engineered from age
121 with fixed premiums and a minimum guaranteed growth rate completely uncorrelated to the market or economy. What this means is that what you want to happen, will happen. A Whole Life policy provides a blueprint guaranteeing policy owners that
their policies will eventually grow to equal the death benefit—even if their not
around to see it.
Furthermore, the PUA rider in an Infinite Banking designed Whole Life policies speed up the
process by turbo-charging the cash values AND death benefit at no future cost. In comparison, IUL is a side savings account based on positive market returns
combined with the rising cost of a one year term policy. While it’s nice IUL’s have the potential for 1-2% higher average returns than Whole Life, returns are dragged down by the rising cost of insurance over time, the unpredictability nature of market returns, and lack of discipline to stick to the planned premium when life events invariably happen.)
Underfunded and/or poor performing IUL policies should not be the foundational basis of a financial plan because IUL's have no guarantee of performance. Just a guarantee of zero AND a guarantee of increasing life insurance costs. As you can guess, I like building a financial plan with growth guaranteed each year and guaranteed fixed premiums that combined create financial certainties... hence Infinite Banking designed Whole Life.
5. Taking income from an IUL during years of low and no return makes the
cash value disappear even faster, especially so when the cost of insurance is
rising exponentially after age 65. It's the triple whammy that can't be avoided: no return, loans coming out, exponentially rising cost of insurance. (This perfect storm of risk is even more pronounced in Variable Universal Life (VUL) policies).
For this reason, I mention an IUL is not suituable for middle class income earners because they won't have a fallback plan if the majority of their eggs are in this one basket. There’s just too many perils for middle class clientele to
navigate to make it their main strategy.
Unfortunately, there is an army of inexperienced life agents and advisors touting an IUL as the best thing since slice bread, and worse yet, people show me their IUL plans that have been designed the wrong way because there is too much death benefit (which means higher commissions for the advisor and an increased likelihood of that IUL to fall short of expectations).
All this said, The Power of Zero with Indexed Annuities is an excellent way
to go because there is no life insurance mortality costs to eat away at the
returns and many indexed annuities can be purchased with no annual fees or if choosing an indexed annuity for income purposes, a guaranteed lifetime income rider that averages 1% per year which is an extremely low cost for the peace of mind knowing you'll always have an income.
My thoughts are if people really want "The Power of Zero" without any true downside risk (no market risk AND no rising mortality costs), then combine IBC designed Whole Life policies with
uncapped Indexed Annuities. You get the best of both worlds (upside growth and the IBC banking strategy) without
taking any unnecessary risk.
And one more thing, remember that if you're doing Infinite Banking right, you will have more than one IBC designed Whole Life policy.
We can discuss further if you like by scheduling time on my calendar here:
www.IBC.guru
Thank you,
John Montoya